For Sale

37 West 12th Street Unit: 5J, New York City, NY 10011

37 West 12th Street Unit: 5J


Rarely available triple mint Classic 7 in the highly coveted Butterfield House located in the heart of the Village Gold Coast. Recently featured in Interior Design magazine, this sophisticated, inviting and comfortable home is ideally designed for both everyday living and gracious entertaining. A welcoming entry gallery with two huge custom fitted closets, opens to a sun-flooded south facing living room overlooking the townhouse gardens from a wall of windows. The living room provides one of the two entrances to the spacious and tranquil private terrace. Also off of the gallery is the dining room with a deep bay window and proportions allowing for a table of twelve. The windowed, eat-in-kitchen with a patterned marble floor has a Wolf stove and hood, Thermador refrigerator, eat-in banquette. An inviting and cozy custom walnut paneled den, located off the kitchen, has an en-suite bath making it perfect for an additional 4th bedroom.

The primary bedroom suite has an abundance of closet space and an en-suite bathroom with Waterworks fixtures. The two additional, south facing bedrooms are generous in size with excellent closet space. A third bath in the bedroom wing has a large Kohler soaking tub and Waterworks fixtures. There is also a powder room located off the foyer, perfectly positioned for entertaining.

This wonderful welcoming and sunny apartment has been thoughtfully renovated to include top of the line finishes, thermostat-controlled air conditioning, wide-plank walnut floors, generous custom closets, sound system, and even a sound insulated front door.

The iconic, award winning Butterfield House is a highly sought after midcentury modern landmark designed by William J. Conklin and James Rossant. This first class full service building is pet friendly and includes full time doorman, resident super and manager, perennial landscaped garden, fitness center, garage (discounted for shareholders), storage (waitlist). 2% flip tax paid by buyer. Assessment: $524/month. This apartment and building are truly special!



Leighton Candler

Leighton Candler

Jennifer A. Reardon

Jennifer A. Reardon

Features & Amenities


  • total bedrooms4
  • Total bathrooms4
  • full bathrooms3
  • half bathroom1
  • Laundry room Building Other
  • other interior Features Separate/Formal Dining Room

Area & Lot

  • Status For Sale
  • MLS® IDRPLU-33422958171
  • TypeCo-Op
  • YEAR BUILT1963
  • NeighborhoodDowntown
  • View DescriptionOther


  • other exterior FeaturesBuilding Courtyard, Balcony


  • Sales Price$4,995,000
  • HOA Fees $5,927/mo
  • Zoning RC


The birthplace of New York City and the nation. A bustling financial hub by day, a residential catch all year round.


You Don't Want to Miss Out!

Sign up for our weekly newsletter to get hot listing updates and real estate market trends.

Thank You

Thanks for signing up!

Work With Us

Leighton Candler and her team strive to assess their customers' specific needs and personality, and then zero in on the right neighborhood, building, and apartment to fulfill their requirements.

Follow Us